Safety and risk
Is a 12% to 15% bond too good to be true?
A 12% to 15% bond is not a scam by default, but the extra yield is payment for risk: a weaker issuer, unsecured or subordinated ranking, a securitised structure, a high yield on a bond that repays principal early, or a bond that is hard to sell. With RBI Floating Rate Savings Bonds paying 8.05% for Jul to Dec 2026, a 14% bond pays about 6 points more, and that gap is the market's price for the chance of late or partial repayment.
Verified
Issuers pay what they must to borrow. A bond app showing 11% to 16% is usually listing companies that cannot borrow more cheaply, or bonds with features that make them worth less than the coupon suggests.
Where does the extra yield come from?
| Source of yield | What to look for | Example on platforms |
|---|---|---|
| Weaker issuer credit | BBB or lower rating, negative outlook | Aspero listed Samunnati Finance at 10% and RDC Concreteindia at 12%, both BB+, on 17th Oct 2026 |
| Split or stale ratings | More than one agency, Issuer Not Cooperating flags | Hella Infra Market at about 15% to 16% on Groww, Aspero, BondScanner and SMEST, showing Acuité's A- while India Ratings had it at B+ Issuer Not Cooperating from 1st Oct 2026 |
| Lower ranking | Unsecured or subordinated | Satya MicroCapital's 14.20% subordinated debt, sold on IndiaBonds at 14.25% in Apr 2025; Satya later breached a net worth covenant |
| Structure | Securitised debt, lease or invoice pools | A Grip affiliate's lease pool rated CRISIL BB- (SO) in Mar 2025 after lessee defaults |
| Early repayment | Principal returned in instalments | TradingQnA users note the yield can look high while rupee returns are small |
| Liquidity | No sell feature, thin exchange trading | Jiraaf does not facilitate resale after purchase |
Sources: Aspero, India Ratings, Groww listing, IndiaBonds archive, Satya annual report, CRISIL, TradingQnA, Jiraaf FAQ.
Does senior secured mean I can't lose money?
No. Senior secured is the label most 2026 forum posts about 12% bonds lean on (Reddit). It means bondholders hold a charge on specific assets and rank ahead of unsecured lenders, which helps recovery after a default. It does not stop the default, and recovery depends on what the assets fetch and how long enforcement takes. TruCap Finance NCDs sold through bond platforms went to CARE D on 18th Jul 2025 and were repaid about 10 weeks late with penal interest (CARE, Catalyst Trusteeship).
How can a yield look bigger than my income?
Put ₹1 lakh in a 2 year bond showing a 10% YTM that repays half the principal after year 1. You receive ₹60,000 after year 1 (₹10,000 interest and ₹50,000 principal) and ₹55,000 after year 2. The rate really is 10%, but total interest is ₹15,000. A 2 year bond paying 10% on the full ₹1 lakh until maturity pays ₹20,000. The yield is correct; your money is simply invested for less time.
What do the apps and the regulator say?
Wint's App Store listing advertises 9% to 12% fixed returns and Aspero's Play Store listing advertises 9% to 13% returns (App Store, Google Play). SEBI's Aug 2026 consultation on a new OBPP advertising code proposed barring high yield or high return claims without a basis and requiring a warning that fixed returns are not guaranteed (Business Today). SEBI's Nov 2025 caution against unregistered bond platforms followed newspaper ads promising unusually high guaranteed returns (Taxmann).
How should I read a 12% to 15% offer?
Check, in this order: the lowest rating and its date, secured or unsecured, senior or subordinated, and how you would sell before maturity. Then put the number after tax: in the 30% slab a 14% coupon is 9.8%, against 5.64% on an 8.05% RBI Floating Rate Savings Bond (RBI). Whether that gap pays for the risk is your call; see are corporate bonds safe and YTM vs coupon.
Sources
- Aspero homepage (live listings, 17th Oct 2026)
- India Ratings on Hella Infra Market, 1st Oct 2026
- Groww listing of Hella Infra Market NCD
- IndiaBonds archived Satya MicroCapital listing, Apr 2025
- Satya MicroCapital annual report FY 2025-26
- CRISIL rationale, PIRG SDI 4 Trust, 12th Mar 2025
- TradingQnA: Wint Wealth bonds for the 30% tax slab
- Jiraaf FAQ
- Reddit: are 12% senior secured bonds a better option?
- CARE Ratings on TruCap Finance, 18th Jul 2025
- Catalyst Trusteeship TruCap status report, 23rd Oct 2025
- Wint Wealth App Store listing
- Aspero Google Play listing
- Business Today: SEBI proposes revamped ad code for bond portals
- Taxmann: SEBI warns against unregistered online bond platforms
- RBI: Floating Rate Savings Bonds rate, Jul to Dec 2026